It has long been recognized that an employee's ability to participate in vocational retraining is a significant factor that must be considered in assessing the worker's permanent disability. (LeBoeuf v. WCAB (1983) 48 CCC 587, 597.) An employee's inability to compete in the open labor market could support an award of permanent total disability. Even though vocational rehabilitation was repealed and replaced with the supplemental job displacement benefit, an employee still can rebut a scheduled rating by establishing that he or she was not amenable to rehabilitation. (Ogilvie v. WCAB (2011) 76 CCC 624.) That's commonly done with evidence from vocational experts.
Special Report - Nunes v. State of California, Dept. of Motor Vehicles: Vocational Apportionment Invalid
Topics: Apportionment, permanent total disability, PTD, Vocational Retraining, Medical Evidence
For injuries on or after Jan. 1, 2013, Labor Code 4660.1(c)(1) states that "the impairment ratings for sleep dysfunction, sexual dysfunction, or psychiatric disorder, or any combination thereof, arising out of a compensable physical injury shall not increase." LC 4660.1(c)(2)(A)(B), however, specifies two exceptions allowing an increased impairment rating for a psychiatric disorder. An employee may receive such a rating by proving that the injury resulted from either: (1) being a victim of a violent act or direct exposure to a significant violent act; or (2) a catastrophic injury. Moreover, the WCAB continues to hold that the permanent disability schedule under LC 4660.1 can be rebutted by vocational evidence.
How should LC 4660.1(c)(1) be applied if the employee is unable to return to the open labor market as a result of his or her physical injury in addition to a compensable consequence psychological disorder? The issue was addressed recently in the case of Schaan v. Jerry Thompson & Sons, 2022 Cal. Wrk. Comp. P.D. LEXIS 264.
Topics: Ogilvie, LC 4660.1(c), catastrophic injury, vocational expert, psychiatric injury, permanent total disability
Subscribe Here!
Recent Posts
Posts by Tag
- Case Law Updates (27)
- COVID-19 (11)
- Announcements (10)
- Special Reports (6)
- Red Alerts (4)
- DWC (3)
- Events (3)
- Medical Treatment (3)
- Press Releases (3)
- QME (3)
- Utilization Review (3)
- cumulative trauma (3)
- Apportionment (2)
- COVID (2)
- California (2)
- Division of Workers' Compensation (2)
- LC 4062.2 (2)
- Laws (2)
- MPN (2)
- Ogilvie (2)
- Permanent Disability (2)
- Petition (2)
- Petition for Reconsideration (2)
- Reconsideration (2)
- Rules (2)
- Workers Compensation (2)
- Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (2)
- permanent total disability (2)
- psychiatric injury (2)
- voucher (2)
- 132a (1)
- 240 Weeks (1)
- 90-day (1)
- AMA Guides (1)
- AME (1)
- Awards (1)
- C&R (1)
- CCR 10396 (1)
- CCR 10607 (1)
- CCR 30 (1)
- CT (1)
- CT injury (1)
- CTE (1)
- Court of Appeals (1)
- Death Benefits (1)
- Defendants (1)
- Earley (1)
- Emergency (1)
- Employee (1)
- Employer (1)
- Evaluations (1)
- FEHA (1)
- Fair Employment and Housing Act (1)
- Fitzpatrick (1)
- Hearings (1)
- IMR (1)
- Insidious Disease (1)
- LC 11663 (1)
- LC 3208.3 (1)
- LC 4610 (1)
- LC 4616.3 (1)
- LC 4660.1(c) (1)
- LC 4909 (1)
- LC 5410 (1)
- LC 5412 (1)
- LC 5500.5 (1)
- LC 5908.5 (1)
- LC 5909 (1)
- Mailbox Rule (1)
- Mandate (1)
- Medical Evidence (1)
- Medical-Legal (1)
- Multiple (1)
- Objective Evidence (1)
- PTD (1)
- PTP (1)
- RFA (1)
- Recon (1)
- Request for Authorization (1)
- Request for a Medical Evaluation (1)
- Romero (1)
- Service (1)
- Special (1)
- Special Adjudication Unit (1)
- Statute of Limitations (1)
- Statutory Presumption (1)
- Striking (1)
- Supplemental Job Displacement Benefit (1)
- Telehealth (1)
- Time (1)
- Trials (1)
- Union (1)
- Urgent Reports (1)
- Vaccine (1)
- Vocational Retraining (1)
- WCAB (1)
- Yanes (1)
- cases (1)
- catastrophic injury (1)
- collateral estoppel (1)
- compensable disability (1)
- credit (1)
- date of injury (1)
- defense (1)
- denial (1)
- disability (1)
- discovery (1)
- dismissal (1)
- expedited review (1)
- further study (1)
- good cause (1)
- lack of persecution (1)
- multiple employers (1)
- new and further disability (1)
- presumption (1)
- proof of service (1)
- qualified medical evaluator (1)
- replacement QME (1)
- res judicata (1)
- return to work voucher (1)
- unpublished opinions (1)
- unrepresented employee (1)
- vocational expert (1)